Mayo instead of butter give a better, tastier crust

Summary Review

Now that we’ve covered both Miracle Whip and mayo on an individual level, let’s summarize to give you a quick reference where you can easily come back to note the similarities and differences in these two products. 

In terms of Miracle Whip vs. mayo, which one wins for you? 

Right away, we notice that Miracle Whip and mayo are often used interchangeably but they are not really the same.

Miracle Whip has sugar and a lot more processing additives in the mix. It cannot be classified as a condiment but rather as a dressing because of how it is made. 

Both of these are made with the same base ingredients of oil, eggs, and vinegar or lemon juice. From there, the mixtures can vary.

Mayo is far heavier on the oil than Miracle Whip is.

The uses for each one are also very similar. When it comes to cooking, they can be used in many ways. It seems like mayo is often the preference for many of these but both actually work. 

When it comes to health uses, mayo is more natural and therefore has more benefits. There are people who use Miracle Whip in place of mayo for many of these things but the known and trusted results typically come from mayo. 

Ultimately, which one you use boils down to personal preference. 


Can I replace eggs with Mayo in brownies?

You can use mayonnaise as an egg substitute in a brownie mix. I have tried a heaping tablespoon and a little extra water. Mayonnaise contains both oil and eggs, so this is not much of a stretch. … Mayo is combination of egg and oil, so it is what the cake need.

Chocolate chip cookies

Shutterstock Shutterstock

If you’ve run out of butter but still crave a warm batch of chocolate chip cookies, don’t throw in the towel just yet. You can whip up the classic cookie with mayonnaise instead. What’s more, you can save those eggs for breakfast because you won’t need them, either. Chef and cookbook author, Rozanne Gold, came up with these gems in a pinch, and in the process discovered a delicious variation on chocolate chip cookies. Bonus? Since mayo is made with vegetable oil, you’ll end up with a healthier chocolate chip cookie that’s just as satisfying as the classic.

8. Vegan Mayo

Vegan Mayo is a healthier alternative to regular mayo and is usually made with some type of plant milk. Soy milk is the best choice to make vegan mayo because it has a similar consistency to cow’s milk.

You can buy vegan mayo or you can also make it at home. Homemade vegan mayonnaise is very inexpensive and made with simple and clean ingredients. Depending on the brand, many store-bought versions taste very similar to regular mayo.

The calories of vegan mayo vary from recipe to recipe but those made from natural clean ingredients tend to be lower in calories than regular mayo.

What can I use in a cake instead of mayo?

Yogurt, Greek or traditional, mimics the creaminess of mayonnaise, but contains less fat, cholesterol and additives. Yogurt is another excellent source of calcium and protein, whether it is the full or non-fat variety.

Does mayonnaise make a cake more moist?

Made from eggs and oil, which are pretty standard cake ingredients, mayonnaise will boost the moisture level in a cake recipe when added to the batter. It might even gussy up your boxed cake mix enough to taste homemade. … Mayonnaise may just become your secret cake ingredient.

IT IS INTERESTING:   How do you cook fully cooked chicken wings?

Baked macaroni and cheese

Shutterstock Shutterstock

One of the hallmarks of great mac and cheese is its creaminess. Many recipes will call for making a milk-flour sauce called a white sauce, or béchamel, to achieve that creamy state. The sauce must be cooked separately before mixing it with pasta and grated cheese and then baking it. Mayonnaise, instead of béchamel, will also give you that desired creamy texture and allow you to skip the step of making the sauce all together. This macaroni and cheese recipe includes a layer of breadcrumbs and parsley for a toasted crunchy topping that’s a pleasing contrast to the casserole’s creamy interior. You can also get a little fancy by using a specialty mayonnaise to elevate everyday macaroni and cheese to a dish like this truffle mac and cheese.

5. Pesto

Pesto is an Italian sauce that is typically bright green and loaded with lots of flavorful ingredients typically olive oil, fresh basil, garlic, hard cheese and pine nuts.

Though neither the flavor nor texture is similar to mayo, it can be used as a substitute for mayo in dishes such as tuna fish salad or sandwiches. Pesto is usually thick and grainy in texture with a bright, fresh but rich nutty flavor.

Pesto traditionally has about 120 calories and 12 grams of fat for every two tablespoons, which is still less than mayo but you can make a lightened-up version of pesto if you use less olive oil and cheese.

What does mayonnaise do in baking?

Made from eggs and oil, which are pretty standard cake ingredients, mayonnaise will boost the moisture level in a cake recipe when added to the batter. It might even gussy up your boxed cake mix enough to taste homemade. While adding mayonnaise to dessert may sound odd, apparently this is an old-timey baking trick.

IT IS INTERESTING:   How long does it take to cook frozen chicken at 425?


Butter has a pale yellow color, and a softer texture than margarine. Butter made from cow’s milk is also easier to melt than margarine. Therefore, the butter is not good for too long kept in room temperature. The aroma of butter is much more powerful and tasty than margarine made from vegetable oil. And because it is made from animal ingredients, butter on the market, has relatively more expensive prices than margarine. Butter is useful for cooking, such as frying and grilling. Butter can also be used for greasing foods such as bread and cake. In terms of its usefulness, butter is better suited in making pastries. Butter contains carbohydrates, fat, vitamin A, and d. Fat in butter is indeed quite a lot. And it is a saturated fat. The consumption of saturated fats and often too much is not good for health, particularly for problems with cholesterol.

– Consist 90 calories in 1 tablespoon – Consist 102 calories in 1 tablespoon
– Has 10 grams of total fat with 2 grams of saturated– Has 12 grams of total fat and 7 grams of saturated
– Contain less cholesterol– Contain much cholesterol

Christine Pittman

Christine is the Senior Editor and Owner of The Cookful and of COOKtheSTORY and of the podcast Time Management Insider. Her sites reach over 2 million readers per month, which means that things can get a bit crazy. She’s constantly writing, taking pictures, editing, recording, interviewing, managing contributors, and, oh yeah, cooking. To say that she wears many hats is an understatement – there are many hats, and also many shirts, shoes, pants, and even the odd cape!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.